[manjaro-general] Still LUKS passphrase is meaningless with Calamares installation.

[MASAKI Yuhsuke]

I reported meaningless passphrase for LUKS emcrypted root filesystem with Calamares installation.
It occured Manjaro 16.08 XFce (x86_64), and it was reproduced on 16.10.1 XFce (x86_64).

[What does]

(16.08)
On hp Z400 workstation with 8disks.
* Choose Language
* Choose Timezone
* Choose Keyboard layout
* Manual Partitioning
- * 1024MiB ext3 boot
- * 250GiB XFS on LUKS root
* Enter user infomation
* Install

(16.10)
On ASRock FM2A88X+Killer with 2disks, UEFI boot.
* Choose Language
* Choose Timezone
* Choose Keyboard layout
* Manual Partitioning
- * sda1 : 300MiB FAT32 esp
- * sda2 : 1000MiB ext3 boot
- * sda3 : 110.5GiB ext4 on LUKS root
* Enter user infomation
* Install

[What happened]

Manjaro boots after 14 seconds from hit enter key when input right passphrase.
Manjaro boots after 28 seconds from hit enter key when input wrong (like "abcde") or empty passphrase.
Manjaro boots after long time (at least more of 30 minutes) when input nothing.


It must input right passphrase when access other system.


Regards,
MASAKI Yuhsuke


You wrote:
> Hi Masaki,
> 
> we had tested the final release and all was fine, working as expected.
> Also I'm about to start the next development cycle for Manjaro 16.10.
> 
> I might release a new ISO soon. If you like you can test the development
> builds to check if you see that error still.
> 
> greez, Phil
> 
> Am 01.10.2016 um 14:01 schrieb MASAKI Yuhsuke:
> > Hi Philip Müller <philm at manjaro.org>, This is MASAKI Yuhuske.
> > Thank you for your e-mail.
> > I reply your e-mail on Fri, 9 Sep 2016 17:28:45 +0200
> > 
> > Sorry, I overlooked this mail.
> > 
> > I installed Manjaro with  manjaro-xfce-16.08-pre5-x86_64.iso.
> > 
> > * The disk is a SSD having blank GPT.
> > * Boot with BIOS, Japanese and non-free driver.
> > * Start Calamares
> > * Use Japanese
> > * Set Asia/Tokyo and Japanese Keyboard
> > * Manual partitioning
> >   part 1 : 1024MB(MiB, sector 2048-2099199) Ext3, /boot
> >   part 2 : left (237.5GiB) XFS, /, with encryption
> > * Set user password and root password. No automatic login.
> > * Finish install.
> > * Reboot.
> > 
> > Behavior. GRUB asks phassphrase for hd0,gpt2 before GRUB menu.
> > 
> > When enter right passphrase, start GRUB menu quickly and boot Manjaro.
> > When enter wrong or empty passphrase, wait to timeout, access all disks, and start GRUB menu and boot Manjaro.
> > When do nothing, wait to timeout, access all disks, and start GRUB menu and boot Manjaro.
> > 
> > 
> > 
> > You wrote:  
> >> Hi Yuhsuke,
> >>
> >> can you be more precise what exactly you did step by step and give us
> >> the exact setup you did.
> >>
> >> kind regards, Phil
> >>
> >> Am 09.09.2016 um 09:47 schrieb Teo Mrnjavac:  
> >>> On giovedì 8 settembre 2016 23:58:15 CEST you wrote:    
> >>>> Some Idea what the user means? I didn't test it by using a blank
> >>>> password yet for luks.
> >>>>    
> >>>
> >>> I most certainly cannot reproduce this on manjaro-kde-16.08-pre5-x86_64.iso
> >>> I've tried a full disk install, Erase, MSDOS partition table and BIOS boot. 
> >>> Only the assigned passphrase unlocks GRUB.
> >>>
> >>> The user's configuration seems to be manual? He's mentioning GPT and a 
> >>> separate /boot partition, but no EFI. I would need more information on what 
> >>> exactly the user did in Calamares, click by click.
> >>>
> >>> Cheers,
> >>>     
> >>  
> 
>